The sentence of three years probation, 500 hours of group service and a $5,000 tremendous for W. Samuel Patten is probably the most lenient up to now in a case associated to Robert Mueller’s investigation. | Jose Luis Magana/AP Photograph
Up to date 04/12/2019 11:45 AM EDT
Fri Apr 12 11:45:16 EDT 2019
A Washington political advisor who helped a Ukrainian oligarch illegally buy tickets to President Donald Trump’s inauguration escaped jail time from a federal choose Friday in a case stemming from Particular Counsel Robert Mueller’s probe.
The sentence of three years probation, 500 hours of group service and a $5,000 tremendous for W. Samuel Patten, 47, is probably the most lenient up to now in a case associated to Mueller’s investigation.
Story Continued Under
Patten pleaded responsible final October to a single felony depend of violating the Overseas Agent Registration Act for failing to register for his work within the U.S. on behalf of Ukraine’s Opposition Bloc and a outstanding oligarch who bankrolled that political social gathering.
Patten was a enterprise accomplice with Konstatin Kilimnik, a Russian-Ukrainian citizen who has been a key determine in Mueller’s investigation. Prosecutors and the FBI say Kilimnik, a longtime aide to former Trump marketing campaign chairman Paul Manafort who was additionally charged in one of many instances in opposition to Manafort, has ties to Russian intelligence providers.
Patten sounded contrite in a quick assertion he made to the court docket.
“I totally acknowledge the seriousness of my conduct and the crimes that I dedicated,” Patten advised U.S. District Court docket Decide Amy Berman Jackson simply earlier than she imposed the sentence. “I behaved as if the legislation didn’t apply to me and that was unsuitable.”
POLITICO Playbook e-newsletter
Enroll as we speak to obtain the #1-rated e-newsletter in politics
By signing up you conform to obtain electronic mail newsletters or alerts from POLITICO. You’ll be able to unsubscribe at any time.
Jackson stated a few of the letters submitted to the court docket by Patten’s buddies appeared to reduce his conduct as negligence and, in a single occasion, merely being “a dolt.”
The choose stated Patten’s actions that violated FARA had been critical and misled the general public.
“None of them had been minor and all of them had been completely intentional,” Jackson stated. “This isn’t a mere technicality and it wasn’t an oversight.”
Patten has been cooperating with Mueller’s workplace and different federal prosecutors since 2017. In written filings prematurely of the sentencing, prosecutors gave Patten excessive marks for his cooperation, noting that he was ready to testify in opposition to Manafort at his trial on Overseas Agent Registration Act-related prices.
That trial by no means happened as a result of Manafort lower a plea cope with prosecutors, though he later breached it by offering false data to investigators.
Investigators and prosecutors interviewed Patten on 9 events as a part of his cooperation, prosecutors stated, though particulars of Patten’s cooperation had been submitted in a submitting the court docket stored secret from the general public.
Attorneys from Mueller’s workplace handed off the case final yr to prosecutors from the U.S. Lawyer’s Workplace in Washington. Whereas attorneys from that workplace dealt with Friday’s listening to, legal professionals from Mueller’s group had been within the courtroom, together with Andrew Weissmann and Brandon van Grack.
Mueller’s workplace is within the technique of disbanding following the submission of the particular counsel’s report back to Lawyer Normal William Barr final month.
Prosecutors filed a proper movement final month asking that in mild of Patten’s cooperation he obtain a lighter sentence than he would in any other case obtain. Nevertheless, they really helpful no particular sentence, consistent with the coverage of Mueller’s workplace.
Patten confronted a most doable sentence of 5 years in jail on the FARA cost, though defendants in white-collar instances not often get something near the utmost. There aren’t any federal sentencing tips in foreign-agent-registration instances, that are not often prosecuted.
As a part of the plea deal, Patten additionally admitted deliberately deceptive the Senate Intelligence Committee and withholding paperwork from the panel.
Nevertheless, protection legal professionals stated Patten’s actions had been largely the results of disorganization and failing to comprehend how vital it was to offer an intensive response to the Senate inquiry.
Patten’s protection confused that he wasn’t in search of to wield affect with the Trump White Home by arranging the tickets for the overseas nationwide, who was not recognized by title in court docket filings. The protection stated Patten truly supported Hillary Clinton within the 2016 election.
“In Mr. Patten’s thoughts, these had been tickets to a post-election social gathering and never an try to affect an election or politician,” the protection wrote in a sentencing submitting. “Extra importantly, he was blinded by a need to accommodate his consumer. Whereas the above explains why Mr. Patten did what he did it gives no justification for his resolution. It was a whole breakdown in judgment and Mr. Patten regrets his involvement with the inauguration tickets.”
However Jackson stated deceptive the Senate was probably the most critical side of Patten’s conduct.
“You hid and misrepresented the true nature of the work on behalf of the Ukrainian social gathering” and the acquisition of the inaugural tickets, the choose stated. “I’m in all probability most troubled by that as a result of it goes past the failure to register.”
Patten’s protection lawyer Stuart Sears stated his consumer had successfully determined to “forfeit” his life’s work as a political advisor by agreeing to cooperate totally with Mueller’s group.
“Mr. Patten had a selection alongside the best way between sort of his profession and aiding the federal government and he selected his nation,” Sears stated.
In the course of the 40-minute listening to, Jackson — who dealt with one of many instances in opposition to Manafort and can also be assigned to the Mueller-related prosecutions of GOP activist Roger Stone and former Obama White Home Counsel Gregory Craig — expressed irritation with the choice by Mueller’s group to not suggest particular sentences in any of the instances it dealt with.
“I’m not precisely positive the place the brand new custom of demurring moderately than making a suggestion comes from. I imagine the wrongdoer could also be within the courtroom,” the choose stated, apparently referring to Weissmann. “I don’t really feel like I ought to simply must learn between the traces.”
Assistant U.S. Lawyer Felix Campoamor-Sanchez stated he was “not at liberty” to supply a urged sentence, however allowed that remaining mute on that entrance was odd for him as nicely.
“That is an exception,” he stated. “I personally have by no means not made a suggestion to the court docket.”
Nonetheless, it appeared pretty evident that prosecutors wished a really mild sentence for Patten and could be glad with mere probation.
“He started cooperating with the federal government immediately,” Campoamor-Sanchez stated. “He was sincere. He was easy….He’s in a way more optimistic place.”
The prosecutor and Jackson did dispute points of arguments Sears put ahead suggesting that Patten’s actions weren’t as critical as different FARA violations as a result of he didn’t search to obscure the last word consumer and easily rendered behind-the-scenes recommendation.
One shock onlooker at Patten’s sentencing Friday: Craig, the previous White Home counsel who was hit Thursday with a two-count false-statements indictment stemming from Mueller’s investigation.
Craig and one among his attorneys, William Murphy, got here into the courtroom about 5 minutes into the sentencing and sat within the third row behind Patten’s household, taking within the proceedings earlier than the identical choose who will oversee Craig’s case.
Craig is about to look earlier than a federal Justice of the Peace later Friday for a proper arraignment on the indictment, which pertains to a report he ready reviewing a controversial trial in Ukraine. His first look earlier than Jackson is about for Monday.
Patten’s household was visibly relieved after the listening to, hugging and shaking fingers.
This text tagged underneath:
Lacking out on the most recent scoops? Join POLITICO Playbook and get the most recent information, each morning — in your inbox.